首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
When the late Isaiah Berlin was knighted, a friend joked that the honour was for his services to conversation. The distinguished
When the late Isaiah Berlin was knighted, a friend joked that the honour was for his services to conversation. The distinguished
admin
2017-04-20
34
问题
When the late Isaiah Berlin was knighted, a friend joked that the honour was for his services to conversation. The distinguished theorist of liberalism was indeed a brilliant talker and feline gossip. Readers of Berlin’s letters will find that same bubbling flow of malice, wit and human insight on the written page.
A first set of letters came out five years ago. To coincide with Berlin’s centenary year—he lived from 1909 to 1997—his literary executor, Henry Hardy, and a team of co-editors have now brought out a second fat volume. The verbal pressure is higher still, for in 1949 Berlin began dictating to a machine.
Biographically the letters take the reader through Berlin’s professional ascent from clever young don to Oxford professor, public educator and transatlantic academic star. They track the consolidation of his social position as an intellectual jewel of the post-war British establishment. Three or four footnotes a page introduce perhaps 1,000 or more politicians, public servants, academics, musicians and socialites whom Berlin knew or talked about. For that alone, his letters are a unique record of a bygone milieu.
Berlin did not write on oath. He ladles praise on correspondents only to dismiss them in letters to others as gorgons or third-raters. During the Suez crisis in 1956 he writes to the wife of the Prime Minister, Sir Anthony Eden, that her husband has shown "great moral splendour". The next letter, to Berlin’s stepson at Harvard, calls the British action "childish folly". His capsule judgments are sometimes apt, sometimes sneering. He calls Sir Peter Strawson, an eminent contemporary philosopher, provincial. Berlin is sharper still on his own thin-skinned self. He belittles his large philosophical gifts, finds publication an agony and worries to correspondents that his work is rot.
Mr. Hardy says that these letters represent perhaps a fourth of those Berlin wrote in 1946-1960. There are none back to him. So here is Berlin in his own ironical voice, as selected by editors. A reader only of these letters may well ask why Berlin had such grateful pupils and devoted friends. And why was he among the foremost liberal thinkers of the age? A selection of old and new tributes, The Book of Isaiah, also edited by the tireless Mr. Hardy, partly answers both questions.
Thinkers such as John Rawls defended liberal principles with more argument. Among historians of ideas, Quentin Skinner did more to professionalise their discipline. No one had Berlin’s gift for dramatising and personalising abstract ideas.
Berlin kept returning to three core convictions. Freedom from constraint by others (negative liberty) is more urgent or basic, he argued, than freedom to realise your potential (positive liberty). The left distrusted that distinction and the right misappropriated it, while philosophers continue to pick it over. He thought, secondly, that liberalism fails if it cannot validate the universal need to belong.
But perhaps Berlin’s strongest conviction was that the basic commitments—to friendship and truth, fairness and liberty, family and achievement, nation and principle—clash routinely and cannot be smoothly reconciled. Thinkers and politicians should admit the conflicts, Berlin implied, and not blanket them with doctrine or tyrannically attempt to subordinate some concerns to others.
The first two of those ideas crop up here and there in these letters. In personal form, that third conviction—that people are to be taken in full, not in formulae—runs throughout, and was surely one source of Berlin’s charm. More volumes of letters are to follow. Readers will wonder what self-mocking Berlin would have made of this growing monument. He was an erudite wit at the dinner table and, as the reader now sees, in his letters. But he was a thinker first, and for his thought there is no substitute for his essays.
According to the passage, Berlin would NOT agree on the idea that________.
选项
A、philosophers should stay away from politics
B、the commitment to liberty is not always higher than to family and friendship
C、people are complicated and should not be oversimplified
D、philosophical theories can be made more interesting
答案
A
解析
推断题。从第四段伯林对苏伊士危机期间英国首相艾登的行为予以置评来看,他是关心政治的,可推测他不认为哲学家应当远离政治,故正确答案为[A]。根据第九段首句可知,伯林坚信“人们对友谊与真理、公平与自由、家庭与成就、民族与原则等事物所承担的基本义务常会彼此冲突,并且不可顺利地调和”,而且主张人们承认这些冲突,而非加以掩盖或试图使其中的某些忧虑屈从于另一些,由此可见,伯林并不认为某些义务是永远高于另一些义务的,第十段也进一步说明,伯林认为人必须全面地加以理解,不能简化为一堆公式,因而[B]和[C]都是符合伯林学说的,故排除;第七段末句指出伯林的特长在于他将抽象观念戏剧化、拟人化地加以表现的禀赋,可推测他应当认为抽象的哲学可以变得生动有趣,故[D]也应当为伯林所赞同的,因此排除。
转载请注明原文地址:https://jikaoti.com/ti/LWeMFFFM
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
AccordingtoMrs.Hammer,whenisthephoneinterviewlikelytotakeplace?
AccordingtoAlan’scoverstory,whatisthedifferenttraitbetweenabossandmostpeople?
Accordingtotheinterview,whatcanhelpustosavetimeindailylife?
Somepeoplesaythatfashionisjustforsellingclothes,soweshouldnotfollowitandweshoulddresswhatwelikeandfeelc
HowtoSpeakGoodEnglishI.IntroductionA.Manylearnershavingdifficultyincommunicatingduetothelackof【B1】______and
MilityHopson’sattitudetowardslendingmoneytofamilyis______.
TheJapanesesaytheysufferfromaneconomicdiseasecalled"structuralpessimism".Overseastoo,thereisatendencytoseeJ
Lettytheoldladylivedina"SingleRoomOccupancy"hotelapprovedbytheNewYorkCitywelfaredepartmentandoccupiedbyold
WhenthelateIsaiahBerlinwasknighted,afriendjokedthatthehonourwasforhisservicestoconversation.Thedistinguished
Therearemorethan300millionofusintheUnitedStates,andsometimesitseemslikewe’reallfriendsonFacebook.Butthes
随机试题
由子宫颈到骨盆侧壁的韧带是
根据《标准施工招标文件》,由施工承包单位提出的索赔按程序得到了处理,且施工单位接受索赔处理结果的,建设单位应在作出索赔处理答复后()天内完成赔付。
钢结构焊接中,可以引弧的构件是()。
负债的特征是()。
下列各项中.免征或不征契税的有()。
依照法律规定冻结存款、汇款的,作出决定的行政机关应当在()日内向当事人交付冻结决定书。
当前我国正处于人口结构高速转变的时期,农村人力资源开发将需要同时面临“农村劳动力转移的难度加大”与“农村劳动力存量的整体素质趋于降低”两大问题。从农业农村发展的要求出发,今后一个时期,开发农村人力资源,优化农村人力资本结构必须着眼于提升农村人力资源的自我发
Shegota______jobwhileshewaswaitingtogototheuniversity.
村民委员会成员每届任期(),可以连选连任。
求直线L:在平面Π:x-y+2z-1=0上的投影直线L0的方程,并求L0绕y轴旋转一周所成曲面的方程。
最新回复
(
0
)