首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
High School Sports Aren’t Killing Academics [A]In this month’s Atlantic cover article, "The Case Against High-School Sports." Am
High School Sports Aren’t Killing Academics [A]In this month’s Atlantic cover article, "The Case Against High-School Sports." Am
admin
2015-03-13
26
问题
High School Sports Aren’t Killing Academics
[A]In this month’s Atlantic cover article, "The Case Against High-School Sports." Amanda Ripley argues that school-sponsored sports programs should be seriously cut. She writes that, unlike most countries that outperform the United States on international assessments, American schools put too much of an emphasis on athletics. " Sports are embedded in American schools in a way they are not almost anywhere else," she writes. " Yet this difference hardly ever comes up in domestic debates about America’s international mediocrity(平庸)in education. "
[B]American student-athletes reap many benefits from participating in sports, but the costs to the schools could outweigh their benefits, she argues. In particular, Ripley contends that sports crowd out the academic missions of schools: America should learn from South Korea and Finland and every other country at the top level of international test scores, all of whom emphasize athletics far less in school. Even in eighth grade, American kids spend more than twice the time Korean kids spend playing sports," she writes, citing a 2010 study published in the Journal of Advanced Academics.
[C]It might well be true that sports are far more rooted in American high schools than in other countries. But our reading of international test scores finds no support for the argument against school athletics. Indeed, our own research and that of others lead us to make the opposite case. School-sponsored sports appear to provide benefits that seem to increase, not detract(减少)from, academic success.
[D]Ripley indulges a popular obsession(痴迷)with international test score comparisons, which show wide and frightening gaps between the United States and other countries. She ignores, however, the fact that states vary at least as much in test scores as do developed countries. A 2011 report from Harvard University shows that Massachusetts produces math scores comparable to South Korea and Finland, while Mississippi scores are closer to Trinidad and Tobago. Ripley’s thesis about sports falls apart in light of this fact. Schools in Massachusetts provide sports programs while schools in Finland do not. Schools in Mississippi may love football while in Tobago interscholastic sports are nowhere near as prominent. Sports cannot explain these similarities in performance. They can’t explain international differences either.
[E]If it is true that sports undermine the academic mission of American schools, we would expect to see a negative relationship between the commitment to athletics and academic achievement. However, the University of Arkansas’s Daniel Bowen and Jay Greene actually find the opposite. They examine this relationship by analyzing schools’ sports winning percentages as well as student-athletic participation rates compared to graduation rates and standardized test score achievement over a five-year period for all public high schools in Ohio. Controlling for student poverty levels, demographics(人口统计状况), and district financial resources, both measures of a school’s commitment to athletics are significantly and positively related to lower dropout rates as well as higher test scores.
[F]On-the-field success and high participation in sports is not random—it requires focus and dedication to athletics. One might think this would lead schools obsessed with winning to deemphasize academics. Bowen and Greene’s results contradict that argument. A likely explanation for this seemingly counterintuitive(与直觉相反的)result is that success in sports programs actually facilitates or reflects greater social capital within a school’s community.
[G]Ripley cites the writings of renowned sociologist James Coleman, whose research in education was groundbreaking. Coleman in his early work held athletics in contempt, arguing that they crowded out schools’ academic missions. Ripley quotes his 1961 study, The Adolescent Society, where Coleman writes, "Altogether, the trophy(奖品)case would suggest to the innocent visitor that he was entering an athletic club, not an educational institution. "
[H]However, in later research Coleman would show how the success of schools is highly dependent on what he termed social capital, " the norms, the social networks, and the relationships between adults and children that are of value for the child’s growing up. "
[I]According to a 2013 evaluation conducted by the Crime Lab at the University of Chicago, a program called Becoming a Man—Sports Edition creates lasting improvements in the boys’ study habits and grade point averages. During the first year of the program, students were found to be less likely to transfer schools or be engaged in violent crime. A year after the program, participants were less likely to have had an encounter with the juvenile justice system.
[J]If school-sponsored sports were completely eliminated tomorrow, many American students would still have opportunities to participate in organized athletics elsewhere, much like they do in countries such as Finland, Germany, and South Korea. The same is not certain when it comes to students from more disadvantaged backgrounds. In an overview of the research on non-school based after-school programs, researchers find that disadvantaged children participate in these programs at significantly lower rates. They find that low-income students have less access due to challenges with regard to transportation, non-nominal fees, and off-campus safety. Therefore, reducing or eliminating these opportunities would most likely deprive disadvantaged students of the benefits from athletic participation, not least of which is the opportunity to interact with positive role models outside of regular school hours.
[K]Another unfounded criticism that Ripley makes is bringing up the stereotype that athletic coaches are typically lousy(蹩脚的)classroom teachers. "American principals, unlike the vast majority of principals around the world, make many hiring decisions with their sports teams in mind, which does not always end well for students. " she writes. Educators who seek employment at schools primarily for the purpose of coaching are likely to shirk(推卸)teaching responsibilities, the argument goes. Moreover, even in the cases where the employee is a teacher first and athletic coach second, the additional responsibilities that come with coaching likely come at the expense of time otherwise spent on planning, grading, and communicating with parents and guardians.
[L]The data, however, do not seem to confirm this stereotype. In the most rigorous study on the classroom results of high school coaches, the University of Arkansas’s Anna Egalite finds that athletic coaches in Florida mostly tend to perform just as well as their non-coaching counterparts, with respect to raising student test scores. We do not doubt that teachers who also coach face serious tradeoffs that likely come at the expense of time they could dedicate to their academic obligations. However, as with sporting events, athletic coaches gain additional opportunities for communicating and serving as mentors(导师)that potentially help students succeed and make up for the costs of coaching commitments.
[M]If schools allow student-athletes to regularly miss out on instructional time for the sake of traveling to athletic competitions, that’s bad. However, such issues would be better addressed by changing school and state policies with regard to the scheduling of sporting events as opposed to total elimination. If the empirical evidence points to anything, it points towards school-sponsored sports providing assets that are well worth the costs.
[N]Despite negative stereotypes about sports culture and Ripley’s presumption that academics and athletics are at odds with one another, we believe that the greater body of evidence shows that school-sponsored sports programs appear to benefit students. Successes on the playing field can carry over to the classroom and vice versa(反之亦然). More importantly, finding ways to increase school communities’ social capital is imperative to the success of the school as a whole, not just the athletes.
Amanda Ripley thinks that athletic coaches are poor at classroom instruction.
选项
答案
K
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://jikaoti.com/ti/m2OFFFFM
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
AccordingtothemostrecentAmericanFreshmansurvey,conductedannuallybytheUniversityofCalifornia,LosAngeles,undergra
HowExerciseCouldLeadtoaBetterBrainA)Thevalueofmental-traininggamesmaybespeculative,asDanHurleywritesinhisa
Spaceexplorationhasalwaysbeentheprovinceofdreamers:Thehumanimaginationreadilysoarswherehumaningenuity(创造力)strugg
Justoveradecadeintothe21stcentury,women’sprogresscanbecelebratedacrossarangeoffields.Theyholdthehighestpol
A、Byusingthecomputers.B、Byreferringtothecataloguethelibrarianhasgiven.C、Byaskingthelibrariantohelpher.D、Byc
A、Shedoessometeachingwork.B、Shedoesherhomework.C、Sheworksasababysitter.D、Sheattendsweekendlessonstoimprovehe
Somethingveryunusualhappenedabout80,000yearsago,asEarth’slasticeagewasgettingstarted.Sealevelsthathadbeendr
CeaseFireinUkraineA)SeparatistleadersinUkraineagreedMondaytojoinagovernmentdeclaredceasefireasafirststeptow
CeaseFireinUkraineA)SeparatistleadersinUkraineagreedMondaytojoinagovernmentdeclaredceasefireasafirststeptow
CeaseFireinUkraineA)SeparatistleadersinUkraineagreedMondaytojoinagovernmentdeclaredceasefireasafirststeptow
随机试题
根据我国《收养法》的规定,收养关系成立的必经程序是【】
继发性肝癌诊断的关键是
患者经过积极治疗病情好转出院,护士告诉出院带药中有一种药物要用黑色纸包裹并避光保存。请问该药物可能是
以下哪项是成熟B淋巴细胞的表面标志
男,62岁,急性重症胰腺炎患者,于保守治疗中,尿量逐渐减少,无尿2d,出现气促、全身水肿。血压180/92mmHg,心率120次/分,听诊可闻及两肺部下野满布湿啰音。查血钾6.9mmol/L,血BUN25.2mmol/L,血肌酐577μmol/L。目前应
关于桡骨小头半脱位,下列哪项是错误的()
2015年初甲股份有限公司(以下简称“甲公司”)股东权益总计为45000万元,其中股本30000万元、资本公积1000万元、盈余公积9000万元、未分配利润5000万元,甲公司2015年发生的有关股东权益业务资料如下:(1)经批准,甲公司以增发股票方式募
下列决策中,最能体现行政领导者决策能力强弱和决策艺术高低能力的是()。
有甲、乙、丙三个盒子,第一个盒子里有4个红球1个白球,第二个盒子里有3个红球2个白球,第三个盒子里有2个红球3个白球,先任取一个盒子,再从中任取3个球,以X表示红球个数.求所取到的红球不少于2个的概率。
A、Theyarenotdevotedtotheirwork.B、Theydon’ttaketheirstudentsseriously.C、Theyareunsatisfiedwiththeequipment.D、T
最新回复
(
0
)