首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
This month Singapore passed a bill that would give legal teeth to the moral obligation to support one’s parents. Called the Main
This month Singapore passed a bill that would give legal teeth to the moral obligation to support one’s parents. Called the Main
admin
2013-06-12
29
问题
This month Singapore passed a bill that would give legal teeth to the moral obligation to support one’s parents. Called the Maintenance of Parents Bill, it received the backing of the Singapore Government.
That does not mean it hasn’t generated discussion. Several members of the Parliament opposed the measure as un-Asian. Others who acknowledged the problem of the elderly poor believed it a disproportionate response. Still others believe it will subvert relations within the family; cynics dubbed it the "Sue Your Son" law.
Those who say that the bill does not promote filial responsibility, of course, are right. It has nothing to do with filial responsibility. It kicks in where filial responsibility fails. The law cannot legislate filial responsibility any more than it can legislate love. All the law can do is to provide a safety net where this morality proves insufficient. Singapore needs this bill not to replace morality, but to Provide incentives to shore it up.
Like many other developed nations, Singapore faces the problems of an increasing proportion of people over 60 years of age. Demography is inexorable. In 1980, 7.2% of the population was in this bracket. By the turn of the century, that figure will grow to 11%. By 2030, the proportion is projected to be 26%. The problem is not old age per se. It is that the ratio of economically active people to economically inactive people will decline.
But no amount of government exhortation or paternalism will completely eliminate the problem of old people who have insufficient means to make ends meet. Some people will fall through the holes in any safety net.
Traditionally, a person’s insurance against poverty in his old age was his family. This is not a revolutionary concept. Nor is it uniquely Asian. Care and support for one’s parents is a universal value shared by all civilized societies.
The problem in Singapore is that the moral obligation to look after one’s parents is unenforceable. A father can be compelled by law to maintain his children. A husband can be forced to support his wife. But, until now, a son or daughter had no legal obligation to support his or her parents.
In 1989, an advisory council .was set up to look into the problems of the aged. Its report stated with a tinge of complacency that 95% of those who did not have their own income were receiving cash contributions from relations. But what of the 5% who aren’t getting relatives’ support? They have several options: (a) get a job and work until they die; (b) apply for public assistance (you have to be destitute to apply); or (c) starve ’quietly. None of these options is socially acceptable. And what if this 5% figure grows, as it is likely to do, as society ages.’?
The Maintenance of Parents Bill was put forth to encourage the traditional virtues that have so far kept Asian nations from some of the breakdowns encountered in other affluent societies. This legislation will allow a person to apply to the court for maintenance from any or all of his children. The court would have the discretion to refuse to make an order if it is unjust.
Those who deride the proposal for opening up the courts to family lawsuits miss the point. Only in extreme cases would any parent take his child to court. If it does indeed become law, the bill’s effect would be far more subtle.
First, it will reaffirm the notion that it is each individual’s -- not society’s -- responsibility to look after his parents. Singapore is still conservative enough that most people will not object to this idea. It reinforces the traditional values and it doesn’t hurt a society now and then to remind itself of its core values.
Second, and more important, it will make those who are inclined to shirk their responsibilities think twice. Until now, if a person asked family elders, clergymen or the Ministry of Community Development to help get financial support from his children, the most they could do was to mediate. But mediators have no teeth, and a child could simply ignore their pleas.
But to be sued by one’s parents would be a massive loss of face. It would be a public disgrace. Few people would be so thick-skinned as to say, "Sue and be damned." The hand of the conciliator would be immeasurably strengthened. It is far more likely that some sort of amicable settlement would be reached if the recalcitrant son or daughter knows that the alternative is a public trial.
It would be nice to think that Singapore doesn’t need this kind of law. But that belief ignores the clear demographic trends and the effect of affluence itself on traditional bonds. Those of us who pushed for the bill will consider ourselves most successful if it acts as an incentive not to have it invoked in the first place.
The author thinks that if the bill becomes law, its effect would be
选项
A、indirect.
B、unnoticeable.
C、apparent.
D、straightforward
答案
A
解析
至于将来该议案成为正式法律后的效果如何,作者的观点反映在这句中:If it does indeed become law,the bill’s effect would be far more subtle.紧接着作者给出了几个例子,说明在许多情况下人们碍于情面,怕失面子而妥协解决问题,故不会有太多的法庭审理。因此,其效果是间接的。
转载请注明原文地址:https://jikaoti.com/ti/u2RYFFFM
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Asanxiety-makers,examinationsaresecondtonone.Thatisbecausesomuchdependsonit.Theyarethemarkofsuccess
ThefirstAmericanwritertousefreeverseinpoetryis
ThefollowingpeoplemetMexicanPresidentEXCEPT
WheredoesthefinancialsupportofElectroOpticSystems’lasertrackingtechnologycomefrom?
Ifitwereonlynecessarytodecidewhethertoteachelementarysciencetoeveryoneonamassbasisorfindthegiftedfewandt
Ifitwereonlynecessarytodecidewhethertoteachelementarysciencetoeveryoneonamassbasisorfindthegiftedfewandt
ThetasteoftheEnglishinthecultivationofland,andinwhatiscalledlandscapegardening,isunrivalled.Theyhavestudied
Materialculturereferstothetouchable,material"things"--physicalobjectsthatcanbeseen,held,felt,used--thataculture
Attheturnofthe18thand19thcenturies_____appearedinEnglandasanewtrendinliterature.
Attheturnofthe18thand19thcenturies______appearedinEnglandasanewtrendinliterature.
随机试题
(2012年4月)中小型企业的地位
机体处于炎热环境中时()。
【2009年第76题】钢筋混凝土梁下部纵向钢筋水平方向净距不应小于1倍钢筋直径,且不应小于下列哪一个数值?
证券投资顾问业务客户回访机制中证券公司应当统一组织回访客户,对新客户应当在()个月内完成回访。
企业所得税前应扣除的广告费和租赁费用为( )万元。当年所得税前应扣除的坏账准备金为( )万元。
中国社会传统的教育观念,总觉得书念得越多越好,从社会角度来说,未必如此。套用“恰当技术”的说法,一个社会的“恰当高学历人群”是随着社会的发展程度浮动的。最近读《洪业传》,写到洪业担任燕京大学教务长,规定学生成绩平均不够乙等,就得退学,实施第一年,400多学
公司规定,将全体职工按工资数额从大到小排序。排在最后5%的人提高工资,排在最前5%的人降低工资。小王的工资数额高于全体职工的平均工资,小李的工资数额低于全体职工的平均工资。如果严格执行公司规定,则以下哪种情况是不可能的?I.小王和小李都提高了工资。Ⅱ.
设曲线y=y(x)满足xdy+(x一2y)dx=0,且y=y(x)与直线x=1及x轴所围的平面图形绕x轴旋转的旋转体体积最小,则y(x)=()
It’sveryinterestingtonotewherethedebateaboutdiversity(多样化)istakingplace.Itistakingplaceprimarilyinpolitical
HehopeshecanvisittheUnitedNationsbuildingwhilehe______inNewYorknextsummer.
最新回复
(
0
)