首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Education Standards Are Not the Answer Sen. Christopher Dodd and Rep. Vernon Ehlers have recently proposed a bill to create
Education Standards Are Not the Answer Sen. Christopher Dodd and Rep. Vernon Ehlers have recently proposed a bill to create
admin
2013-07-11
30
问题
Education Standards Are Not the Answer
Sen. Christopher Dodd and Rep. Vernon Ehlers have recently proposed a bill to create a national curriculum in reading and math. The bill’s supporters rightly tell us that by the end of high school, American students have fallen behind their international peers. Dodd and Ehlers use that observation to conclude that we need such a curriculum "to compete in the global economy." But how exactly would homogenizing our curriculum and testing make us more competitive? "National standards would help propel U.S. economic competitiveness, because they would allow the country to set expectations higher than those of our international competitors," write Rudy Crew and Paul Vallas, the superintendents of the Miami and Philadelphia school districts, in a recent Education Week commentary.
This idea of higher standards has a certain appeal. In many other areas of life, higher standards are associated with better performance. It’s much harder to qualify for a U. S. Olympic team than for a typical high school sports team—and Olympic teams are demonstrably better. Japanese automakers generally set higher reliability standards in the 1970s than did American automakers, and they produced more reliable vehicles. But sports and manufacturing are competitive fields, while public schooling currently is not. Standards advocates mistakenly assume that high external standards produce excellence, but in fact it is the competitive pursuit of excellence that produces high standards.
Michael Petrilli, a scholar at the Ford-ham Foundation, recognizes the role of competition in education, but contends that national standards are necessary to facilitate it. In order for any market to work effectively, Petrilli claims, "consumers need good information," and in his view, that information can only be delivered by a national system of standards and tests.
Yet around the world, free education markets are already thriving with no such standards in place. One such market exists in the United States: after-school tutoring. By contrast, there is no evidence that imposing government standards improves the performance of true education markets. On the contrary, by placing all intellectual eggs in the same basket, a single national curriculum would hamper competition and magnify the damage done by every bad decision.
As Jared Diamond so compellingly argued in his Pulitzer Prize winning Guns, Germs , and Steel, diversity is as important to the health of human societies as it is to the survival of ecosystems. We need education diversity as much as we need biodiversity. A dynamic, competitive system is better able to survive mishaps than a monolithic, centralized one.
It is ironic that standards advocates urge us to improve our schools in response to competitive pressures from abroad, but then discount the ability of the same competition and consumer choice to drive improvement at home. It is the competitive pursuit of excellence spurred by market forces that drives up standards, not the other way around. The sooner we realize that, the better off our children will be.
Paragraph 2 is written to show the proposal of the national education standards______.
选项
A、fails to reflect the uniqueness of education field
B、has a weak theoretical grounding
C、is doomed to receive a disagreement
D、discounts the benefit of the internal competition
答案
B
解析
本题考查写作目的。第一段介绍了国家课程设置的目的:通过设定高标准提高学生的竞争力。这说明该提议的理论依据为:高标准产生高质量。第二段对此依据进行了讨论:首先,以运动业和制造业中的实例说明该理论具有一定的合理性。倒数第二句用转折连词but引出作者真正要表达的思想:不同于运动业和制造业的是,教育行业并非竞争性领域,所以并非高标准产生高质量。并在末句进一步否定了该理论:在教育领域,不是“外在的高标准会创造卓越品质”而是“追求卓越的竞争产生了高标准”。可见,作者是运用该段内容否定教育标准的理论基础。[B]正确。第二段旨在说明“高标准产生高水平”这一准则不适用于教育领域,而非突出教育领域与众不同的特点。[A]错误。该段只是论述了在教育领域中建立高标准没有理论依据,并没有进一步说明这一提议势必不会被认可。[C]言辞过于激烈。考生误选[D]是因为对该段末句中的external理解错误:external并非将竞争区分为“内部竞争”和“外部竞争”,而是指出教育的“外在标准”和“自身质量”的关系。
转载请注明原文地址:https://jikaoti.com/ti/TuRYFFFM
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
AlicewasaB-plusstudentthroughherfirstthreeyearsatcollege.Duringthewinterholidaysinhersenioryear,whileshe
随着西藏改革开放和现代化的发展,藏语翻译也得到了迅速发展,1993年成立了西藏翻译工作者协会,并先后成立了拉萨市和日喀则地区分会;共举办了7期翻译培训班,培训337人次;1994年在西藏举办了全国第二次暨西藏首届藏语文翻译学术研讨会,并先后派人员参加了在北
Whatnewseventisreported?
Thecharacterof______isrepresentativeoftheEnglishbourgeoisieattheearlierstagesofitsdevelopment.
In1896aGeorgiacouplesuingfordamagesintheaccidentaldeathoftheirtwoyearoldwastoldthatsincethechildhadmade
TheInfluenceofRomeEmpireonToday’sSocietyI.OverallIntroduction:Manyaspectsoftoday’ssocietyhavebeenaffectedbya
Iknownowthatthemanwhosatwithmeontheoldwoodenstairsthathotsummernightoverthirty-fiveyearsagowasnotatall
InLondonsomegenerationsagopeopledidn’tgotothecinema,theywenttothe"pictures".Atripwasagrandevent,areasont
WhyweretherehundredsofmournersintheAustraliancityofNewcastlewhogatheredtomournthedeathoftwentypeoplekilled
1925年2月24日,国父孙中山病危时,留下一段《家事遗嘱》:“余因尽瘁国事,不治家产。其所遗之书籍、衣物、住宅等均付吾妻宋庆龄,以为纪念。余之儿女已长成能自立,望各自爱,以继余志。此嘱。”中山先生艰苦奋斗40年,功勋卓然。但终身廉洁,
随机试题
肾表面有3层被膜,它们是()
提高硝酸盐的耐受性,可同时用的制剂是
6岁猫,施卵巢子宫切除术,用非吸入麻醉,其首选麻醉药是
临床上主要采用的牙种植体为
生产的植物油闪点大于60℃,植物油浸出车间为单层厂房,每层建筑面积为125m2,且同一时间的作业人员不超过10人,所以浸出厂房的安全出口最少应有()。厂安全主管甲的有些观点是错误的,下列说法错误的有()。
对于维持具体行政行为的行政复议决定,申请人逾期不起诉又不履行行政复议决定的,由行政复议机关依法强制执行,或者申请人民法院强制执行。()
根据《最高人民法院关于适用若干问题的规定(三)》的规定,出资人以其他公司股权出资,人民法院应当认定出资人已履行出资义务的条件有()。
下列关于审计工作底稿的说法中,正确的有()。
下列道教宫观中,()享有“道观之祖”之美誉。
Fortheadvertisedposition,thecompanyoffersa(n)_____salaryandbenefitspackage.(2010-79)
最新回复
(
0
)