首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Is the professional book reviewer old-fashioned? In a recent Harvard Business School study of nonfiction reviews, assessments in
Is the professional book reviewer old-fashioned? In a recent Harvard Business School study of nonfiction reviews, assessments in
admin
2013-09-16
39
问题
Is the professional book reviewer old-fashioned? In a recent Harvard Business School study of nonfiction reviews, assessments in mainstream media outlets and amateur ratings on Amazon largely converged. Assuming we can trust the questionable verdict of mere consensus, surely we could dump the Review section and decide what to read purely by consulting peers online?
Nevertheless, traditional reviewers still serve a function. Few Amazon users will explore a book with the depth of an 800-word review. Supportive quotes are a virtual obligation of the form in print, since especially appraisals of style require substantiation, yet most Amazon reviewers applaud or deplore an author’s prose without providing examples, and you just have to take their word for it. Granted, critics are often scorned as clubby in-fighters either championing their friends or settling old scores.
Yet many Amazon reviewers are just as snotty, overblown and acid as the worst of the "tits" in the Times Literary Supplement. A few small-minded pros may indeed be brown-nosing or out for revenge, but most critics with a shred of integrity refuse to review authors they know. Besides, Amazon suffers from corruption as well; friends-and-family boosters can inflate a listing with flattery; rivals and personal adversaries can pump it with poison. Some review sections may be suspected of assigning books whose publishers advertise in the paper, but Amazon’s emailed "recommendations" are paid for by publishers, no doubt.
As for accuracy of assessment, Amazon reviews tend to gather populist momentum, mix together into a group-think that discourages dissenters. Able to check online for what’s already out there before filing, insecure professional critics are likewise prone to go safely with the popular tide. But the best reviewers will stick their necks out, sometimes defending a misunderstood book against a deluge of denunciation, or objecting that a fashionably crowned "masterpiece" isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.
Still, when executed responsibly, reviewing requires many hours of reading that modest fees don’t begin to compensate. Reviewers are not all grinding an axe or scratching a back. They try to put an author’s work in context, to advance a more constructive argument than "I didn’t like it", and to make a few halfway amusing observations along the way. When they pan a work, hoping to save you time and money, they risk making an enemy of the author for life.
Anyway, why not read the Review section and go online? Then, if both the pros and the amateurs turn out to be wrong, these days you’ve got multiple forums in which to say so. I might defend the reviewing trade, but a handful of haughty hired hands no longer having the last word on books is not a bad thing. According to that Harvard study, professional critics are influenced by awards and hype, while regular readers are less prone to being concealed and more open to new writers. So between the two sources, we should all find the ultimate
Holy Grail.
It is indicated in Paragraph 4 that amateur reviews______.
选项
A、enjoy great popularity
B、encourage multiple perspectives
C、are highly accurate
D、lack unique opinions
答案
D
解析
[A]选项陷阱在于段中首句提及“业余评论集结平民论者力量”。但文意旨在说明“业余评论犯了群体思维错误,没有独到见解”,并不能引申推出“业余评论很受大众欢迎”,故排除。[B]选项误将文意“业余评论排斥不同意见”反向曲解为“业余评论提倡多角度思维”,故错误。[C]选项陷阱在于段落以“评论准确度”开启,但文意在说明“业余评论者的准确度由于趋同思维而降低”,本选项和文意相反。
转载请注明原文地址:https://jikaoti.com/ti/IXYRFFFM
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Accordingtotheauthor,Mr.ArnoldSchwarzeneggerischeerfulchieflybecauseItcanbeinferredfromthetextthat
Inmostpartsoftheworld,climatechangeisaworryingsubject.NotsoinCalifornia.AtarecentgatheringofgreenLUMINARIE
Punishmentdependsasmuchonpoliticsasitdoesoncrime:crimerateshavebeenstableinrecentyearsbutthere’sbeenastri
Punishmentdependsasmuchonpoliticsasitdoesoncrime:crimerateshavebeenstableinrecentyearsbutthere’sbeenastri
Punishmentdependsasmuchonpoliticsasitdoesoncrime:crimerateshavebeenstableinrecentyearsbutthere’sbeenastri
Punishmentdependsasmuchonpoliticsasitdoesoncrime:crimerateshavebeenstableinrecentyearsbutthere’sbeenastri
Punishmentdependsasmuchonpoliticsasitdoesoncrime:crimerateshavebeenstableinrecentyearsbutthere’sbeenastri
Punishmentdependsasmuchonpoliticsasitdoesoncrime:crimerateshavebeenstableinrecentyearsbutthere’sbeenastri
随机试题
下列叙述中正确的是
翼下颌间隙内的结构主要有
关于民用建筑工程室内环境中污染物浓度检测的说法,错误的是()。
若企业融资成本为12.88%,则下列项目可行的有()。
下列筹资方式按一般情况而言,企业所承担的财务风险由大到小排列为()。
某公司2018年财务报告批准对外报出日为2019年4月30日,所得税汇算清缴于209年4月15日完成,下列事项中属于发生在日后期间的调整事项的有()。
幼儿园教育工作的评价以()为主。
1956年美国教育心理学专家布卢姆制定了目标分类系统,下列与认知目标、情感目标共同构成三大教育目标的是()。
()对于逻辑相当于烹饪对于()
译审
最新回复
(
0
)