首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Ah, the naivety of the older generation. Nearly 500 eminent astronomers, biologists, chemists, physicists and earth scientists h
Ah, the naivety of the older generation. Nearly 500 eminent astronomers, biologists, chemists, physicists and earth scientists h
admin
2017-02-28
25
问题
Ah, the naivety of the older generation. Nearly 500 eminent astronomers, biologists, chemists, physicists and earth scientists have been surveyed to identify the "core traits of exemplary scientists". Their answer? Honesty is critical, second only to curiosity, and we ought to do more to instil it in those considering science careers.
Ironically, they are deceiving themselves. Researchers have never been whiter than white. Here are a couple of revealing numbers. About 2 per cent of scientists admit to at least one act of research misconduct. But as a whole, researchers say that around 14 per cent of their colleagues are involved in such behaviour. Someone’s not being straight.
Those figures come from a 2009 meta-analysis (far more scientifically reliable than a single sample of " honoured" academics) , that also found one-third of scientists confessed to "questionable research practices" such as cooking data, mining it for a significant result that is then presented as the original target of the study, selective publication or concealing conflicts of interest.
We may never know for sure how widespread such behaviour is. According to another meta-analysis published in October, scientists are becoming less likely to admit to fabrication, falsification or plagiarism. That study also found that researchers see plagiarism as more heinous than making results up. They are more likely to report a colleague they catch in an act of plagiarism than one fabricating or falsifying data.
How can this be so, when honesty is supposedly such an essential attribute? Because it gets the job done. Raymond De Vries at the University of Michigan and colleagues have argued that data manipulation based on intuition of what a result should look like is "normal misbehaviour." They see such common misbehaviours as having "a useful and irreplaceable role" in science. Why? Because of "the ambiguities and everyday demands of scientific research."
In other words, data isn’t often as clean as you would like. According to Frederick Grinnell, an ethicist at the University of Texas, intuition is " an important, and perhaps in the end a researcher’ s best, guide to distinguishing between data and noise." Sometimes you just know that data point was an anomaly to be ignored.
Should we do something to make science more virtuous? Probably not. Those eminent academics questioned for the survey by Michigan State University, which was released today at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, are hopelessly optimistic when it comes to improving ethical standards: 94 per cent of them said students can learn scientific values and virtues from "exemplary scientists."
According to Frederick Grinnell, intuition can serve as
选项
A、a judge.
B、a critic.
C、a guide.
D、a challenger.
答案
C
解析
(1)根据题干关键词Frederick Grinnell定位至第6段。其实,第5、6段都在分析“研究者对捏造或编造数据持有宽容态度的原因”。(2)根据文章,Frederick Grinnell认为“直觉是重要的,也许最终是最佳向导”(第6段:guide)。其实,有关直觉的作用在第5段就已经提到了(第5段:intuition,normal misbehavious)。故答案为选项[C]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://jikaoti.com/ti/CZr7FFFM
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Doyourememberallthoseyearswhenscientistsarguedthatsmokingwouldkillusbutthedoubtersinsistedthatwedidn’tknow
Scientistshavefoundthatalthoughwearepronetosnapoverreactions,ifwetakeamomentandthinkabouthowwearelikelyto
ThejournalScienceisaddinganextraroundofstatisticalcheckstoitspeer-reviewprocess,editor-in-chiefMarciaMcNuttann
Arecentstudy,whichwaspublishedinlastweek’sJournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,offersapictureofhowriskyit
Wemaintainthatingeneralafocusonpositiveinformationbenefitswell-being.However,thereareprobablyconditionswhenac
Wemaintainthatingeneralafocusonpositiveinformationbenefitswell-being.However,thereareprobablyconditionswhenac
Comparisonsweredrawnbetweenthedevelopmentoftelevisioninthe20thcenturyandthediffusionofprintinginthe15thand1
Comparisonsweredrawnbetweenthedevelopmentoftelevisioninthe20thcenturyandthediffusionofprintinginthe15thand1
Comparisonsweredrawnbetweenthedevelopmentoftelevisioninthe20thcenturyandthediffusionofprintinginthe15thand1
Youngpeoplealwayssufferinrecessions.Employersstop【C1】______thembecausetheyareeasiertosack.Butin【C2】______episod
随机试题
目前信息安全传送的标准模式是()
历代医籍中把哪些病称为积聚
国际法基本原则的特征之一是各国公认,这意味着()。
()负责期货投资者保障基金业务监管,对保障基金的筹集、管理和使用等情况进行定期核查。
下面有关证券交易所总经理的表述错误的是()。
企业向银行借入长期借款,若预测市场利率将上升,企业应与银行签订()。
非公有制经济作为促进经济社会发展的重要力量,是我国社会主义市场经济的重要组成部分,是为社会主义服务的。非公有制经济在促进经济社会发展过程中的作用,具体体现在
A、 B、 C、 B
ManagementinCyberspaceVirtualrealityisoftenusedtomimichazardousenvironments—cockpitsofcombataircraft,burning
TheFrenchgovernmentistobanstudentsfromusingmobilephonesinthecountry’sprimary,juniorandmiddleschools.Children
最新回复
(
0
)